The Old Timers' Athletic Association of Mamaroneck-Larchmont, NY honors one male and one female multi-sport student-athlete each year for an outstanding record in athletics, citizenship, and scholarship at Rye Neck High School. This award not only emphasizes the student-athlete's performance on the field or court, but also emphasizes their performance in the classroom and their contributions to their community. Any recipient of this award embodies the true meaning of a student-athlete and is a leader on and off the field. This distinction is awarded to very few and is the highest honor a Rye Neck Panther Student-Athlete can receive.

Ayla Felenstein

Induction: 2025

Sean Mohr

Induction: 2025

Blathnaid Grenouillon

Induction: 2024

David Goldin-McCarthy

Induction: 2024

Joseph Lavelle

Induction: 2023

Olivia Tobin

Induction: 2023

Evelyn Picone

Induction: 2022

Ben Taffet

Induction: 2022

Max Saltus

Induction: 2021

Stephanie Santoli

Induction: 2021

Matthew Quartararo

Induction: 2020

Julianne "Juju" Spencer

Induction: 2020

Colin Kelley

Induction: 2019

Charlotte Murphy

Induction: 2019

Conor Liguori

Induction: 2018

Samantha Yannuzzi

Induction: 2018

Cristal Finkenberg

Induction: 2017

Logan Spencer

Induction: 2017

Allison Baal

Induction: 2016

Conner Sexton

Induction: 2016

Nicole Miller

Induction: 2015

Chris Richart

Induction: 2015

Jakob Calvini

Induction: 2014

Samantha Espada

Induction: 2014

Ryan Baal

Induction: 2013

Nickole Morgan

Induction: 2013

Julia Bilotta

Induction: 2012

Brendan Crowley

Induction: 2012

Vanessa Laise

Induction: 2011

David Mendoza-Conner

Induction: 2011

Jeff Colangelo

Induction: 2010

Georgia Richardson

Induction: 2010